Pre-auction offer or hedge my bets and wait for auction?

In Melbourne’s bustling property market, the strategy of making a pre-auction offer has become increasingly common among buyers eager to secure their dream home. As the real estate landscape continues to evolve, understanding the positives and negatives of this approach is crucial for prospective buyers looking to navigate the competitive market terrain effectively.


Potential to Secure the Property

Making a pre-auction offer provides buyers with the opportunity to secure their desired property before it goes to auction. This can be advantageous in competitive markets where multiple buyers are vying for the same property. By putting forth a strong offer early on, buyers may avoid the uncertainty and potential bidding wars that often accompany auctions.

Negotiating Power

Submitting a pre-auction offer can give buyers greater negotiating power, especially if the seller is motivated to sell quickly. With fewer competing offers on the table, buyers may have more leverage to negotiate favourable terms, such as price adjustments or inclusion of additional amenities. This can lead to a smoother and more favourable transaction for both parties involved. If there is strong interest in the property, this strategy won’t be beneficial unless the offer is very strong.

Avoiding Auction Stress

Auctions can be stressful and unpredictable events, with emotions running high and bidding wars driving up prices. By making a pre-auction offer, buyers can bypass this stress and uncertainty, potentially saving themselves time and emotional energy. It allows for a more controlled and strategic approach to purchasing a property. It is imperative to understand how the agency will handle multiple offers, so you can decide on the best strategy. All agencies are different, so knowing the ‘rules of the game’ is essential.

Opportunity for Early Settlement

A pre-auction offer may also open the door for an early settlement, allowing buyers to move into their new home sooner rather than later. This can be particularly appealing for those with time-sensitive needs or those eager to start the next chapter of their lives in their new home. It can also be worthwhile considering this strategy if you happen to have two properties of interest being auctioned on the same day.


Risk of Overpaying

One of the primary concerns with making a pre-auction
offer is the risk of overpaying for the property. Without the transparency of an auction setting, buyers may struggle to gauge the true market value of the property and could end up paying more than they intended. Thorough research and consultation with real estate professionals are essential to mitigate this risk.

Limited Time for Due Diligence

In the haste to submit a pre-auction offer, buyers may have limited time to conduct thorough due diligence on the property. This could include inspections, appraisals, and assessments of the property’s condition and market value. Rushing through these processes may lead to overlooked issues or unforeseen expenses down the line.

Potential for Rejection

Despite the advantages of making a pre-auction offer, there is no guarantee that the seller will accept it. They may choose to proceed with the auction in hopes of achieving a higher sale price or may receive competing offers that are more appealing. In such cases, buyers risk investing time and effort into an offer that ultimately does not result in a successful purchase.

Missing Out on Auction Dynamics

Participating in an auction provides buyers with valuable insights into market sentiment and competing buyer behaviour. By making a pre-auction offer, buyers may miss out on this firsthand experience, which could impact their future buying decisions and strategies.

In the current Melbourne property market, where early offers are increasingly common, buyers must be prepared to act swiftly and decisively. With the potential for interest rate decreases later in the year expected to bring more competition into the market, now could be an opportune time to consider making a pre-auction offer. However, it is essential for buyers to weigh the positives and negatives carefully and to seek guidance from experienced professionals to make informed decisions.

In conclusion, while making a pre-auction offer in the Melbourne property market can offer several advantages, including the potential to secure a property quickly and negotiate favourable terms, it also comes with risks such as overpaying and limited time for due diligence. By carefully assessing the market conditions and conducting thorough research, buyers can increase their chances of success and navigate the complexities of property purchasing with confidence.

If you are looking to purchase a property and unsure of what the best strategy is, contact the expert team at The Property Bureau on 0408 166 944 (Kristy Caskey) or 0450 109 243 (Alastair Mairs).

Picture of Kristy Caskey

Kristy Caskey

Kristy prides herself on making her clients feel welcome, understood and in safe hands from their very first meeting. With over 20 years' experience in the Melbourne property market it has taught her to ensure every ‘i’ is dotted and ‘t’ crossed and how imperative this is when transacting property.